Monday, September 12, 2011

Chester Gillette and Grace Browns Love letters

The so-called "love letters" that were exchanged by Chester and Grace in 1905 and 1906 were used at the trial by both the prosecution and the defense. Most of them were written by Grace during the time she was home in South Otselic, when she was pregnant and waiting for Chester to come and take her on their trip together. Chester’s letters back were short and less dramatic.

Ward found Chester’s letters to Grace in her trunk. He found most of Grace’s letters to Chester in his room in Cortland. However, the last and most famous letter, was not found until many weeks later when Chester’s landlady was tidying up the room. It was hidden in Chester’s collar box.

Ward read the letters in such a dramatic way during the trial that reporters claimed that every eye in the room was wet and they did much to paint exactly the picture of her that he wanted: the pleading pregnant girlfriend who wants to get married. However, the letters never mention pregnancy or even marriage. They do mention suicide and were used by the defense to back up Chester’s story that she committed suicide.

As a means of reconstructing the relationship, the letters are quite frustrating. They seem inconsistent and it could be that there were more letters that never got entered into the record. Ward’s own numbering system seems to imply that there are letters that are missing.


I found this at http://www.craigbrandon.com/cgfaq.html#2 I found this pretty interesting though. It shows that Chester Gillette could have been innocent. i can't imagine someone knocking someone else off a boat with a tennis racket. It just seems so stupid. If he wanted to murder her, he would have been much better off doing it with a knife or a gun... The way he supposedly did it, there was a whole lot of evidence against him.

7 comments:

  1. Cool i thought that the letters mentioned her being pregnant and that she wanted marriage! i didn't know that the talked about suicide.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Annapoorna since leaving her body in the lake suggests that he pushed her over the edge, but then again, he could have just planned poorly or not at all. I wonder who Ward is though. I haven't heard about him in the book, but by what's written on the post above, it sounds like he had a big part in this murder case...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh-Ward was the district attorney who convicted Chester Gillette of the murder of Grace Brown. The sites i found below give more detail on the evidence gathered on this case. However, the case was built off of circumstantial evidence.

    http://www.uticaod.net/site_html/SPECIAL_CONTENT/gillette/pdf/2B.pdf
    http://www.wardspond.com/history2.html
    http://www.wardspond.com/history.html

    ReplyDelete
  4. I could not sentence someone to death like that!!! take their lives away. That judge is really strong!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Maybe he couldn't swim either, so when she jumped off, He didn't want to jump in and save her, because then they would both die..

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oh! I have a better one..
    It says he took his suitcase and a tennis racket with him, so maybe he was going to take her somewhere far off, kill her, then run. That way ,it'd take a while to find her body and if they do, it'd take so long that the evidence would be erased. But, one thing led to another, she started getting suspicious and asking questions like where they weer going, why they were out so far, so she suddenly figured it out, and he knew she was going to put on a fight, so he just threw her out of the boat and started hitting her with the tennis racket. I saw somewhere that she was less the 100 lbs, so that would have been pretty easy to do.

    ReplyDelete
  7. IF YOU'VE READ THE ASSIGNED READING FOR THIS WEEK: Chester knew how to handle a boat....this could be considered evidence of the murder...

    ReplyDelete